Train vs Plane

Traveling is a fantastic opportunity to explore new cultures and escape the monotony of daily life. One of the first considerations that often srpings to mind is choosing between train and plane – a decision that can shape the entire journey. Both personal preferences and practical aspects come into play here.

Train journeys offer numerous benefits. They provide easy access to transportation links and are an environmentally friendly alternative to flying. However, they also come with downsides, such as longer travel times and a limited number of direct connections, which can be a hassle for some travellers. Conversely, planes are synonymous with rapid travel over long distances, though they are not without their own challenges.

This article aims to shed light on the various facets of train and plane travel – from travel time and comfort to available amenities. The goal is to clearly illustrate when it might be more advantageous to opt for the train over the plane.

What are the Benefits of Train Travel?

Train journeys offer several compelling advantages over flying. Not only are they more environmentally friendly, with significantly lower CO2 emissions per passenger-kilometre, but they also enable travellers to use their time effectively – whether working, reading, or simply relaxing and enjoying the scenery.

Many railway companies are enhancing the comfort of their services with offerings like WiFi and power outlets at the seats. As environmental awareness grows, more people are choosing trains over planes for longer distances. Another plus is the burgeoning network of night trains in Europe, which provides comfortable options for long journeys.

Easy Access to Transport Links

The choice between plane or train as a mode of transport depends on various factors, including travel duration, comfort, and flexibility. Here are some points favouring train use:

• Power Outlets and WiFi: Modern trains often feature power outlets directly at the seats and free WiFi access. This allows travellers to use their time productively, whether by working or preparing for meetings during the journey.
• Time Efficiency: Despite the perception that flying is faster, train travel can often be more time-efficient when considering the total journey time. Factors like getting to the airport, security checks, and potential flight delays can negate the supposed time savings of flying.
• Extensive Rail Network: In Europe, travellers benefit from an extensive and reliable rail network. Connections are typically easy to book and are available at reasonable prices.
• Fewer Travel Complications: Unforeseen flight cancellations, often accompanied by additional costs and inconveniences, are less common in train travel.

Ultimately, the decision between flying and taking the train hinges on the specific travel route and personal priorities. Nevertheless, trains offer noteworthy advantages due to their amenities and the convenience of direct connections to many cities.

Eco-friendly Options

Train journeys are among the most environmentally friendly ways to travel, especially when compared to flying. On average, a train trip produces up to 96.5% fewer CO2 emissions than a comparable flight. For this reason, environmentally conscious travellers often choose trains over planes.

A report by Greenpeace highlights that on approximately a quarter of the 114 European routes examined, train tickets are not only more eco-friendly but also cheaper than plane tickets. Take the Berlin to Prague route, for instance. Travelling by train here not only saves time and money – it’s also 30 times more environmentally friendly than flying.

Businesses are increasingly prioritising sustainability, leading to a rise in corporate train travel. Business travellers are opting for trains to reduce their company’s carbon footprint. However, a lack of reliable and comfortable direct connections means many still choose to fly for shorter distances, negatively impacting the environmental balance.

So, why not hop on the train more often? Less stress and doing a bit for the planet – sounds like a fair trade, doesn’t it?

Comfort and Generosity on the Journey

For those travellers who value a stress-free experience, trains offer clear advantages. On an ICE trip to Berlin, one can not only catch up on work or get engrossed in a book, but also stretch their legs and take a stroll. This significantly adds to a relaxed travel vibe.

When it comes to space, trains particularly shine on longer journeys. There is generally more room and legroom compared to aeroplanes, making them a decidedly more comfortable option. Another bonus: Train travel is more eco-friendly. Planes, on average, generate higher CO₂ emissions per passenger and kilometre. In business class, where more space per passenger is available, the emissions are even higher.

Thus, the mode of transport impacts both the comfort during the journey and the ecological balance. So, travelling by train makes double the sense: delightful and green!

What are the Drawbacks of Travelling by Train?

Though train journeys have numerous merits, there are aspects travellers should keep in mind:

• Complex Fare Structures: Some railway companies have rather perplexing fare systems. This can make booking and planning a bit tricky, requiring patience and a detective’s intuition.
• Transfer Times: Depending on the connectivity, the time between the station and city centre can vary greatly. This can be tedious, especially if connections aren’t ideal.
• Station Wait Times: The average waiting time before and after the train journey is about 32 minutes. While this is shorter than the roughly 157 minutes spent when flying, it can still be seen as a nuisance – particularly if the train is delayed.
• Higher Costs: Train travel can often be pricier than flying, which might deter budget-conscious travellers. Especially with spontaneous bookings or on long routes, the price difference can be noticeable.

Despite these challenges, train travel remains an attractive option for many – be it for environmental reasons or enhanced comfort. It’s worth carefully weighing the pros and cons before choosing the appropriate mode of transport.

Travel Times Might Be Longer

When comparing travel times between flying and taking the train, several factors come into play that can affect the total journey duration. An example is the route from Bern to Paris:

By Plane:

• Actual flight time: 1.5 hours
• Transfer to departure airport: ~60 minutes
• Pre-departure waiting time: ~90 minutes
• Arrival airport waiting time: ~30 minutes
• Transfer from arrival airport to city: ~45 minutes
• Total travel time: around 5 hours and 15 minutes

By Train:

• Total travel time: 4 hours and 34 minutes

Although the actual time in the air with the plane might be shorter, the additional steps significantly extend the total travel time. The transfer to the airport, hours spent at the airport before the flight, and subsequent transfers after landing all contribute to making the overall flight journey considerably more time-consuming than a train journey.

Various studies suggest that on European routes, train travel can often be faster than flying. Therefore, all aspects of the journey should be carefully considered when deciding between the train and the plane to make the most efficient choice.

Limited Direct Connections on Certain Routes

On many European routes, travellers face a choice: plane or train? Analysis shows that out of 419 possible train routes, only 114 offer direct connections, while 335 routes have direct flights.

This means direct trains are almost three times less common than direct flights, making the latter a more convenient choice for most travellers. The lack of direct train connections often nudges people towards opting for the plane.

To promote train travel, we need better connections and a more user-friendly booking system. This will not only make train travel more comfortable but also a genuinely eco-friendly alternative to flying.

Advantages of Flying

Flying offers a range of benefits over other modes of travel, especially for long distances and international connections.

Flying can often be more cost-effective than travelling by train, particularly on international routes to Spain, Italy, the United Kingdom, the Nordic countries, and France. Budget airlines, which serve around 80 percent of European routes, frequently entice with subsidised prices that can be lower than train fares.

Moreover, flight prices are variable and can fluctuate significantly, occasionally making air travel a more affordable option compared to train services.

For long-distance travel or when suitable train connections are lacking, flying is often the only viable choice. On certain routes, the cost difference between air and rail travel is not clearly defined, meaning that flights can sometimes be a competitive alternative under specific circumstances.

Faster Journeys Over Long Distances

The decision between plane and train heavily hinges on the length and destination of the trip. For longer distances, planes often take the cake, being typically quicker than cars, buses, and even high-speed trains. This can be a real time-saver for lengthy routes.

However, there are routes in Europe where trains outshine planes, saving up to two hours of travel time. This is largely thanks to the highly developed rail networks in certain countries. France, Spain, and Belgium boast some of the fastest trains, while Austria and the Netherlands have comparatively slower services.

Vienna is a prime example, leading the charts with the highest number of direct connections in the European rail network. It is closely followed by cities like Budapest, Prague, and Berlin, which also feature excellent connectivity.

Comparing Rail Services in Europe: Popular Cross-border Routes

Country	Fastest Trains	Slowest Trains	Top Speed	Key Routes
France	TGV, Eurostar	TER	320 km/h	Paris – London, Paris – Brussels
Spain	AVE	Regional Train Network	310 km/h	Madrid – Barcelona, Madrid – Seville
Belgium	Thalys	IC	300 km/h	Brussels – Amsterdam, Brussels- Paris
Germany	ICE	Regional Trains	300 km/h	Frankfurt – Amsterdam, Berlin – Warsaw
Italy	Frecciarossa	Regionale	300 km/h	Rome – Milan, Venice – Trieste
Netherlands	NS International	Intercity Express	200 km/h	Amsterdam – Brussels, Rotterdam – Antwerp
Austria	Railjet	Regional Trains	200 km/h	Vienna – Bratislava, Vienna – Salzburg
Switzerland	ICN (InterCity Neigezug)	RegioExpress	200 km/h	Zurich – Innsbruck, Geneva – Lyon
Hungary	Intercity	Regional Trains	160 km/h	Budapest – Vienna, Budapest – Bratislava
Czechia	Pendolino	Osobní vlak	200 km/h	Prague – Bratislava, Prague – Munich
Denmark	Lyntog	Regional Trains	180 km/h	Copenhagen – Malmö, Copenhagen – Hamburg
Sweden	X2000	Regional Trains	200 km/h	Stockholm – Oslo, Stockholm – Malmö
Finland	Pendolino	Intercity	220 km/h	Helsinki – St. Petersburg, Helsinki – Tampere
Portugal	Alfa Pendular	Regional Trains	220 km/h	Lisbon – Madrid, Porto – Coimbra
Norway	Vy	Regional Trains	210 km/h	Oslo – Stockholm, Bergen – Stavanger

This overview showcases the excellent connectivity between European countries, providing insights into cross-border rail travel. Fast connections make travelling in Europe both convenient and eco-friendly.

However, expanding new railway lines across borders is a complex and time-consuming task due to varying regulations and requirements.

For longer distances, flights often remain the quicker choice, despite the potential and many advantages of the European rail network.

Drawbacks of Flying

Flying might be one of the quickest options for long journeys, but there are several drawbacks to consider:

• Challenges for Families: Limited space for children, few play areas, and difficult interactions with other passengers, which can lead to boredom for the young travellers.
• Extended Travel Times: Getting to the airport and long waiting times before departure. Additional time is needed for security checks and check-in procedures.
• Stress Factors: The necessity to be at the airport hours before the flight and the added stress from security measures.
• High Costs: Plane tickets are often more expensive than train tickets. Complications from baggage restrictions and check-in requirements can also arise.

Higher CO2 Emissions

In the debate over environmentally-friendly modes of transport, CO2 emissions play a crucial role. Comparing planes and trains in this context, the difference is stark: a return journey by plane for one person typically produces approximately 227 kg of CO2, while the same trip by train emits only 7.4 kg. This represents a staggering difference of 96.5% fewer CO2 emissions in favour of train travel over flying.

Data on CO2 Emissions:

Mode of Transport	Average CO2 Emission (Round Trip per Person)
Plane	227kg
Train	7,4kg
Savings	96,5% less with train

On a global scale, air travel contributes about 3% to worldwide CO2 emissions. Particularly noteworthy are short flights, which account for a quarter of the EU’s aviation emissions, highlighting their detrimental impact on the climate.

Despite the clear environmental advantage of train travel in terms of CO2 emissions, less than 7% of passenger transport in Europe is conducted by train. This means that a significant portion of journeys still results in considerable environmental harm.

Airport Annoyances and Delays

Airports and flights often encounter a fair share of annoyances and delays. Here’s a quick rundown of the frequent issues passengers face:

Common Airport Annoyances

The top grievances for passengers at airports and on flights include:

• Delays and flight cancellations
• Overbooked flights
• Lost or damaged luggage
• Seat reservation issues
• Long wait times at security checkpoints
• Unpleasant behaviour from other passengers (e.g., loud conversations, seat kicking)

Causes of Flight Delays

Flight delays can arise from various reasons:

• Airspace congestion (around 11% of cases)
• Issues within the airlines themselves (about 8% of cases)
• Weather conditions
• Technical problems
• Strikes

Passenger Rights in the EU

In the event of delays and other issues, passengers in the EU have specific rights:

• A delay of 3 hours or more entitles passengers to compensation of up to 600 euros.
• In cases of cancellations: the right to a refund or alternative transport.
• For overbooked flights: the right to receive financial compensation.
• In cases of lost or damaged luggage: potential compensation payments.

Travel Time Comparison: Train vs Plane

When travelling, total journey times are a crucial factor, often misinterpreted in favour of air travel.

For instance, a train journey from Bern to Paris takes approximately 4 hours and 34 minutes. In contrast, when considering all factors – such as transfers and waiting times – the total travel time for flying increases to around 5 hours and 15 minutes, despite the actual flight being merely 1.5 hours. Additional steps like airport transfers, security checks, and airport wait times significantly extend the overall journey duration.

On various European routes, train travel can often be faster than flying. Studies, like those by Thomas Sauter-Servaes, highlight that when comparing door-to-door travel times, flights are frequently longer than initially perceived. A lack of consideration for transfers and security checks can lead to a mistaken belief that air travel is inherently faster.

Comfort and Experience: Train vs Plane

Choosing between train journeys and flying hinges not only on duration and cost but also on comfort and travel experience. Train travel often benefits from more space and less hassle, which is especially advantageous for those needing to work during the trip. However, train passengers may sometimes face limitations with Wi-Fi or mobile connectivity.

Waiving baggage restrictions and check-in processes simplifies the journey and increases flexibility. Train travellers can enjoy the passing scenery directly and disembark at any station, whereas the view from an airplane is typically limited.

The relaxed atmosphere and opportunities to rest on a train contribute to an overall more pleasant travel experience, often leading to a preference for trains over planes.

The design of a train station and the comfortable environment of a train significantly influence the overall travel impression, while airports are often perceived as stressful and hectic places.

Seat Comfort and Space

Seat comfort and space comparison between train and air travel:

Passengers choosing the train as their mode of transport often enjoy additional comfort and a relaxed ambiance during the journey. For instance, the seats in the first class of Amtrak, as experienced on the Vancouver to Seattle route, provide a comfortable way to observe the landscape rolling by. Long-distance trains also offer the option of a complimentary seat reservation, if available, enhancing travel comfort substantially.

For groups travelling together, it’s possible to reserve adjoining seats, optimising the seating arrangement and allowing the group to spend the journey together. Families enjoy further benefits, as children aged 0-5 years can travel for free when accompanied by an adult.

In contrast to air travel, train travel not only addresses seat comfort but also the broader travel experience, including boarding and alighting. For instance, travellers don’t need to factor in hours of waiting time before departure at an airport or consider the transfer time to a train station at the airport.

On the whole, travelling by train contributes to a fuller sense of wellbeing, offering a more stress-free and enjoyable travel experience.

Onboard Catering

Train catering quality can vary greatly. Some trains feature dining cars with freshly prepared meals, while others have only vending machines. The quality of the coffee can sometimes be disappointing.

Airlines often place a higher emphasis on catering. Even in economy class, there’s usually a hot meal on long-haul flights. The coffee tends to be of better quality than on trains. Many airlines also offer special menus, available by pre-order, such as vegetarian, kosher, or halal options.

Entertainment

Trains typically don’t have an onboard entertainment system. Passengers are expected to bring their own forms of amusement. But no worries, this has its perks: there’s more space for reading, working, or simply enjoying the view. Many trains offer WiFi, so you can surf the web or stream movies on your own device. Perfect for those who prefer a bit of flexibility.

Aeroplanes, on the other hand, often boast integrated screens offering a wide selection of films, TV shows, and games—especially on longer routes. You can sit back and enjoy the latest blockbusters or get lost in an intriguing series. For those not so keen on tech, many airlines still offer traditional in-flight magazines and newspapers.

Passenger Rights and Compensation

Travellers expect a punctual and reliable journey, but delays or cancellations do sometimes occur. When this happens, there are specific rights and compensation claims passengers should be aware of.

EU Rights for Train Delays and Cancellations

Passengers on Deutsche Bahn trains can receive compensation for delays under certain conditions. Here’s a quick rundown:

• For delays of 60 minutes, passengers are entitled to compensation amounting to 25 per cent of the ticket price.
• If the delay reaches 120 minutes or more, the compensation rises to 50 per cent of the ticket price.
• Certain extraordinary circumstances, such as extreme weather, may preclude the need for compensation.
• Strikes by railway staff do not fall under these exceptions, meaning compensation must be provided as these are not considered extraordinary circumstances.
• In the case of train cancellations, passengers are entitled to a full refund of the ticket price, regardless of the cause.

Season ticket holders (e.g., with a Deutschland-Ticket or Jobticket) also have rights to compensation, just like occasional travellers.

Knowing these rights is essential for enforcing them. Passengers should adhere to these guidelines and submit claims to the railway company if delays or cancellations occur.

Rights for Flight Delays and Cancellations

Air travellers, too, often face delays and cancellations. Specific rights apply under the European passenger rights regulation.

It’s important to note that airlines are only responsible for transportation up to the booked arrival airport. Additional travel costs, such as for a train after arrival, are not covered by the airlines. If a flight delay results in missing a connecting train with a fixed schedule, passengers themselves must cover the cost of a replacement ticket.

For passengers who book their ticket, including the journey to the airport, through Rail & Fly with a travel agency, it’s noteworthy that the travel time indicated on the ticket serves only as a guideline. The ticket is valid the day before the flight and on the day of departure.

When Should You Choose the Train Over the Plane?

The decision between taking the train or flying hinges on numerous factors. A survey reveals that 45% of travellers would prefer the train if the connection were faster. This makes train travel not only efficient but often more practical.

From a cost standpoint, the train holds several advantages. According to Greenpeace, train tickets are cheaper than plane tickets on roughly a quarter of European routes. And when it comes to environmental concerns, train journeys are much greener, producing up to 30 times fewer greenhouse gases compared to flights.

Although train rides might take longer, they often come with fewer stressors and offer a more relaxed travel experience. Especially on European routes, the train is often the wiser choice—comfortable, eco-friendly, and sometimes even faster than one might expect.

All in all, the train isn’t just a green option but also a stress-free alternative to flying, making it ideal for the environmentally conscious traveller.

How can Flightright help you?

Flightright is here to help you claim compensation for flight delays. We aim to make the process straightforward and stress-free. We also take into account special circumstances, such as denial of boarding due to illness or disability. Our experts leverage their extensive knowledge of EU passenger rights to secure the compensation you deserve. Visit our website to quickly check your eligibility and enforce your rights.

Your trip is well planned and the children are sleeping peacefully, but now the airline is getting in the way of your holiday happiness? Your flight is overbooked, delayed or cancelled? Has your luggage been delayed or lost?

According to the UK261 Legislation, passengers are entitled to compensation in the event of a delay, cancellation, overbooking, or missed connection. They can receive up to £520 compensation per person (minus the success commission). This compensation is independent of the ticket price. Flightright enforces your right for you. If necessary also in court.

Tip: Flightright helps you to enforce your passenger rights! With us, you can check your claims free of charge in two minutes. ✔️Easy, ✔️fast ✔️& without risk

As the market-leading consumer portal, Flightright fights for the enforcement of air passenger rights. We stand up for your rights in the event of a flight delay, cancellation or denied boarding and refer to the UK261 Regulation. Flightright’s air passenger rights experts are also happy to help you with ticket refunds and refunds for cancelled package holidays.

Check your right for compensation now !

As experts in the field of air passenger rights, we enforce your right to compensation against the airline!